Risk Management Tidbits

Reprinted from Municipal Insurance Association of BC Newsletter

Home  Back  Newsletters

The Rising Cost of Insurance 

The cost of insurance is once again rising in leaps and bounds. The insurance market has for years suffered from underwriting losses during a very competitive market, in which insurance companies competed for increased market share by charging fewer premium dollars for a risk in anticipation that their investments would offset any underwriting loss. During this competitive period local governments benefited from extremely low rates charged for property insurance as well as other lines of insurance. Increases in insurance also reflect a rise in the cost of claim settlements and from large natural losses, such as the "Ice Storm" of 1998, as well as other natural disasters that have occurred around the world, including European floods and tornados and hurricane losses in the United States. The events of September 11, 2001 have also played a significant role in insurance, however insurance rates were rising prior to this terrorist act.

Sport and Recreation increases for 2003 have been rumored to be between 30% and 40%, the cost to insure a small 10 minute Santa Clause Parade in Northern British Columbia was quoted at $750.00, Doctors for Professional Sport have had their insurance cancelled. We have also been advised that a contractor on Vancouver Island, responsible for sewer and water maintenance, a $28,000 a year contract, was quoted $16,000 for liability insurance. MIA has received numerous requests from Water and Improvement Districts for membership in the Association because their cost of insurance has dramatically been increased. MIA is not able to accommodate these requests as set out in the Reciprocal Agreement between members.

What does all this mean to local government? More and more community groups will be approaching local officials with a request that local government insure their activities and events. MIA is not a commercial insurer and we cannot offer insurance beyond the services that are provided by and supervised by local government. MIA itself expects a second year of large premium increases for reinsurance.

Spring Clean-Up Plans

To reduce the potential for accidents to occur member municipalities may wish to consider having their local newspapers do a story on your Spring 2003 clean up plans to remove excess sand from winter road maintenance and the potential for injury to cyclists and scooters, who may injure themselves from their failure to drive with due care.

To protect your municipality from having to contribute to the settlement of an injury claim we strongly suggest that records be kept of when and where municipal crews have operated sweepers and / or where manual clean up operations have occurred. In addition crews should be encouraged to keep an eye open for other potential hazards such as pot holes, damaged sidewalks and missing signs, to name a few and that crews should report these hazards to their supervisor for follow-up. Supervisors should determine whether or not the hazard must be flagged to prevent injuries to the public or scheduled for future repair.

Cause & Effect

 

 The following list of causes and effects reflect new claims brought against local government in the past 3 months. Cause Effect / Injury  

                      

 

Cause 

Effect / Injury 

Uneven sidewalk Broken foot
Sewer-back-up Subsiding foundation
Hole in deck Broken leg
 Road repair vibration Cracked ceiling
Walkway design / steep hill Slip and fall / hip injury 
Metal pole dropped on customer Bruised foot / unable to work
Goat attacked customer  Bruised stomach & neck whiplash 
Missing road sign  MVA/ broken foot / car destroyed 
Pot hole Contusions to knee, arm and hand
Water main rupture  Building and contents damaged
Loose manhole cover Two vehicles damaged
Vacant lot hidden hole Leg, back and neck injury
Defamation  Loss of reputation
Building inspection error  Roof separation
Boat launch platform separated Cut foot requiring stitches
Cyclist hit pedestrian on trail  Broken teeth & wrist
Fireworks went astray Vehicle damage & hand injury 
Collapsed chair Neck and back